The Moonstone: Wilkie Collins

[poliphilo]

T.S. Eliot called The Moonstone the first and greatest of English detective novels. I've held that statement up to the light and looked at it from every angle- and actually I don't see what's wrong with it. If there are earlier examples they've fallen into obscurity and if there are greater examples I don't know what they are.  It's the liveliest and most thoroughly entertaining of the four Collins novels I've read, though not perhaps the best. The best is No Name.   As always with Collins there's a lot of subversion going on and (something for which he doesn't get enough credit) plenty of delightful social comedy.  It may also be the first English novel of any substance to suggest that Empire equals theft. 

Comments

[dakegra.livejournal.com]

Did you see any of the adaptations that were on over christmas? I was quite taken with them, having heard of (but not read any) Just William before.

That said, the books are an order of magnitude superior.

[poliphilo.livejournal.com]

I'm afraid I missed those. Apparently the kid who plays William is pretty good. I remember an 1970s adaption which had some useless child actor as William and Bonnie Langford (who is an acquired taste but not useless) as Violet Elizabeth.