A Good Man?

[poliphilo]

If a good man does bad things is he still a good man?

Or- to narrow things down more specifically to the career of Gordon Brown- can a person claim to be in possession of "a moral compass" if he never seems to use it.

The defining characteristics of Brown's career have been cowardice, lack of principle, corrosive ambition, sulkiness, disloyalty and double-dealing. He tacitly supported the Iraq war, encouraged the banking free for all, created a culture of paranoia around himself, persistently undermined his colleagues- including Tony Blair- and (behind closed doors) sulked and fumed and bullied. In what way are these the actions of a "good" man?

I'm asking  because I've just been reading this. Gordon Brown has failed in most things, but he's somehow managed to sell us all on the notion that he's a moral person- that whole son of the manse thing.   Well, I beg to differ.

Comments

[veronica-milvus.livejournal.com]

He's a financial boffin - no "social graces" for which read, spin-ability. He's very smart, probably slightly Aspergers, and is no sort of leader. Couldn't even spell charisma. He's not a bad man, but he has been in the wrong job.

[poliphilo.livejournal.com]

A job he wanted very badly, and sulked about- to the detriment of his working relationship with his boss.