Sir Salman

[poliphilo]

I don't mind it when an actor becomes a knight. Actors are for hire. (I first wrote "actors are whores"- and withdrew it. But which is it better to be- a whore or a hireling? Think on't.)

Sportsmen and women too: no-one expects them to be deep thinkers or anything other than politically naive.  Nice one, Sir Beefy; you've earned it.

Writers are different.  Writers need to guard their independence. How do you speak truth to power when power is your friend and patron?

I'm thinking about Salman Rushdie of course. We believed he was one of us and it seems he is one of them. Browning said it best-

Just for a handful of silver he left us,
Just for a riband to stick in his coat.

Browning was thinking of Wordsworth (though he always- politely- denied it). We love the young revolutionary Wordsworth of Tintern Abbey and Intimations of Immortality. The older Wordsworth with his government pension and his unread theological epics is a bit of a joke.

The least likely people have turned down knighthoods. Kipling for instance. Yes, he supported the Empire and all that- but always on his own terms. 

Here's what Salman said in a press release: "I am thrilled and humbled to receive this great honour, and am very grateful that my work has been recognised in this way."  O, good grief- you're the author of Midnight's Children, Salman; that's your glory.

The Islamic fundamentalists have always viewed Salman as the running dog of Western Imperialism. In the past we were able to say, no, he's a lone, brave voice- an honest man- answerable to no-one.  But this latest development sort of undermines our case, doesn't it?

Comments

[zeeshanmn.livejournal.com]

But this latest development sort of undermines our case, doesn't it?

It does, absolutely.

[solar-diablo.livejournal.com]

Western Imperialist lackey or not, I think when major Islamic figures suggest a suicide bombing is in order to "correct" England's error (and then slyly state they were misinterpreted when called on it) what it undermines more is the notion that Islam should be regarded as a religion of tolerance and peace.

There's too many Muslims in the world who need to evolve past the mentality that murder is an appropriate response to dissent against their faith.

[senordildo.livejournal.com]

I'm not so sure that accepting a knighthood makes him an Imperialist lackey or answerable to anyone--a knighthood is just an honor, and carries no real obligations. Unlike poor old Wordsworth he's not dependent on the government for his pay, and he's not a laureate writer with an obligation to write for a country. It's not as if the Queen is going to bang on his door and demand he give his knighthood back if he ever wrote something critical of Britain.